‘Real action’ is removing statues instead of improving schools or saving black lives

Symbols are important. Symbols communicate more viscerally than words. Think of the Statue of Liberty, the Arc de Triomphe, the Vietnam Wall, or the crucifix. At the other end of the ledger, Lenin’s Tomb, the swastika, and, yes, a triumphant Confederate general astride a prancing horse.

If Madison had a symbol, it would have to be the peace sign.

Madison scrounges for subtle indications of long-ago intolerance while moms walking toddlers to their first day of school find shell casings on the sidewalk.

How different is that from ISIS defacing ancient Assyrian ruins that preceded the one true religion of Islam (albeit writ in lower case)?

Think Paul Soglin and substitute Madison when reading the following:

“What New York’s mayor wouldn’t give for a larger-than-life Robert E. Lee bronze in full ‘Gone With the Wind’ glory that he could order taken down,” William McGurn writes in today’s Wall Street Journal.

Mr. de Blasio is hardly the only pol to grandstand here. But as mayor of the nation’s largest city — and America’s self-styled progressive-in- chief — his eagerness helps illuminate why these hunts for hate hold such an attraction for the Democratic left.

One big reason is that the left’s identity politics is not about healing old wounds. It’s about picking at them. Is there anyone in New York who believes a de Blasio panel rummaging through the city’s monuments for evidence of “hate” will contribute to either greater reconciliation or a deeper appreciation for the complexities of the Civil War?

“Railing at dead white hateful males is lots more fun than doing the hard work required to improve city life for New Yorkers. Because in the real world, the progressive agenda doesn’t work very well, McGurn writes in a piece titled “A Confederacy of Dunces; Mayor Bill de Blasio goes hunting for ‘hate’ on New York City property.”

Lacking same, New York’s finest minds are evil-eyeing a statue of the first conquistador, Christopher Columbus. The irony is that Civil War-era New York, if not sympathetic to the Confederacy, was antagonistic to the Union cause. It voted McClellan over Lincoln. Let’s not forget the draft riots of 1863 when mobs hunted down and killed free black people.

Lacking same, Madison must settle for a plaque that referred to soldiers who died in squalid captivity as “unsung heroes.” (“Mayor Soglin vows no rest for traitors.”)

Socialist organizer John Nichols is of the same mind. One of the Comrade’s favorite targets is Paul Ryan. His “pronouncements are not enough,” Nichols scolds.

It’s time for real action, like removing Confederate statues and firing Stephen Miller.

“Real Action!” REAL ACTION!!!

Statues that never troubled Nancy Pelosi, Harry Reid, or Barack Obama.

Back to William McGurn:

Now, if Mayor de Blasio [or Paul Soglin] were truly looking to tear down monuments that actively contribute to racial injustice, he would find plenty in his city. These include a failing public school system in which only a small fraction of African-American students test at grade level; a new, state-mandated $15 minimum wage, which will further price young black men out of jobs when it goes into effect; and the misguided welfare programs that undermine the black family.

Just try find traction in teachers-unionized Madison for a Madison Prep or, for that matter, a Montessori charter school. Instead, hear the call for more free stuff and pricing young people out of the workforce.

About David Blaska

Madison WI
This entry was posted in Madison city government, Progressives, Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to ‘Real action’ is removing statues instead of improving schools or saving black lives

  1. Gary L. Kriewald says:

    In today’s “Daily Cardinal,” readers are treated to reactions to the defacement of the Police Memorial on the Capitol Square. Here’s what the head of UW-Madison’s College Republicans had to say: “[We] stand with law enforcement and condemn this vandalism on a monument dedicated to those who have given the ultimate sacrifice to their communities.” Here’s what the head of the College Democrats had to say: “The current system has failed many communities of color, and it is not our role to police their responses to oppression.” Want to take bets on which point of view enjoys overwhelming support on campus–including, I suspect, close to 100% among faculty and administrators?
    It’s always easier to attack symbols (especially those you’ve unilaterally designated as ‘hateful’) than to rationally examine an issue; of course, to do the latter, you need a forum in which all points of view can be heard, debated, and criticized without fear of retaliation or censorship. Alas, such a forum no longer exists at most colleges, certainly not at places like UC-Berkeley or UW-Madison.


  2. Dan B. says:



  3. Tom Paine says:

    Nichols is a commie/collectivist apologist. When he appears on Wisconsin Public (aka Socialist) Radio, he is unopposed, totally in violation of WPR’s own ethical and journalistic standards. Joy Cardin’s latest session served up uncritical, softball questions for Nichols all hour.

    Balance? Critical thinking? Socratic dialogue about public issues? Of course not. It is “progressive” Public Radio, an institution in the service of the the Democratic(communist) party.


  4. madisonexpat says:

    Don’t see murderous gangbangers….. Confederates!
    What failing students from failed families? We look for long dead traitors.
    We see no failed governance…. only bad police.
    Ah Madison….. what did you do to deserve this government?


  5. coolkevs says:

    Graffiti in James Madison park – most likely by young punks (and possibly by the other side), but will get exposed bigly just as if Walker, Vos, and Fitzgerald came down and did it themselves. Will you disavow?????


  6. Marcus says:

    Antifa and BLM deface police memorial and left yawns. Communist celebration memorial defaced in misguided retaliation and left cries anti-Semitism.


    • Gary L. Kriewald says:

      Yes, it’s clearly an anti-Semitic outburst by white supremacists … who were considerate enough to ignore a synagogue only a few feet away! Attack the right in Madison and you’re a heroic social warrior, attack the left and you’re engaging in hate speech. At the risk of employing a cliche, what goes around, comes around. Soglin had to destroy a Confederate memorial in a cemetery, some punk had to deface the Police Memorial on the Square, now the left is suffering a near-fatal dose of the vapours because their little commie memorial got embellished by “street artists” (as the left likes to call them when they’re defacing the right things).


Comments are closed.